Grading the 2024 Washington Nationals: position player edition

Jacob Young makes a sliding catch in a July 3 game. (Photo by Sol Tucker for TalkNats.com)

Last week, we took an unsparing look at how the Washington Nationals pitching staff fared in 2024. Today, we’re grading the rest of the roster: position players, including designated hitters, who don’t actually play a real position but whatever.

As usual, player grades are arbitrary, although I’ve tried my best to be fair. I’ve also graded players against expectations. To earn an A, a player would have to exceed reasonable expectations for themselves and their role on the team. For a B, a player would have to generally meet expectations. A C grade is on the borderline, as it’s a passing grade but generally indicates a player could have done quite a bit more (in my view) with the opportunities they were given. A D grade represents a qualified failure, as the player had their moments, but ultimately, they did not make a good case in the time they had; many of my D recipients were ultimately demoted or designated for assignment during the season. An F grade is reserved for truly disastrous seasons, usually over a sustained period of time and despite many opportunities.

Continue reading
Posted in Roster | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Juan Soto Contract Options

There is no doubt that Juan Soto will test the waters of free agency — even if he eventually signs back with the New York Yankees. The Yankees and Mets are listed as the top two favorites to land him. On one sports betting site, they are taking early prop bets on Soto’s contract over/under which is set at $500 million, and then you can bet on the team that signs him. The Washington Nationals are in their top-half of teams, and tied at 13th with Houston in top odds to sign Soto.

The Shohei Ohtani contract was for the highest pitcher/batter contract in baseball history as he is a starting pitcher and DH. One thing we all expect is that Soto will sign for stupid crazy money and be poised to set a record for a pure position player on a free agent deal. He actually could have set the record in 2022 when the Nats offered him $440 million with room to negotiate that further. Truth be told, Soto wants to test free agency — and the mighty Yankees cannot dissuade him from filing as a free agent. He has earned that right. The Yankees will have to compete for Soto’s services with probably a handful of teams that will be offering over half-a-billion-dollars.

Continue reading
Posted in Analysis, Feature | Tagged | Leave a comment

A Muddy History: The Evolution of Baseball Mud

A Seemingly Mundane Substance with a Rich History

Baseball mud, a seemingly mundane substance, plays a crucial role in the game. It is used to condition baseballs, enhancing their grip and durability. While it may seem like a simple product, the history of baseball mud is surprisingly rich and complex.

Continue reading
Posted in Feature | Leave a comment

Grading the 2024 Washington Nationals: pitching edition

Kyle Finnegan pitches in a win August 9, 2024. (Photo by Sol Tucker for TalkNats.com)

While we enjoy watching the MLB postseason, the Washington Nationals are once again playing golf in October. And that means it’s time again for our annual look at how each National performed in 2024.

Players here are assigned a letter grade or an “incomplete”. I would encourage you not to read too much into minuses or pluses, and to keep in mind that there is somewhat of a grading curve in effect. The expectations for a journeyman pitcher are and should be entirely different than the expectations for an established member of the team. Similarly, the expectations for a rookie aren’t the same as the expectations for a veteran. And, indeed, the expectations for a guy making the major league minimum are less than they are for a guy raking in tens of millions of dollars. (You know of whom I speak.)

Continue reading
Posted in Bullpen, Roster, Starters | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Take Me Out to the Ball Game: A Timeless Anthem

A Century-Old Classic

“Take Me Out to the Ball Game” is more than just a song; it’s a cultural touchstone that has captivated audiences for generations. Its enduring popularity is a testament to baseball’s timeless appeal and the music’s power to evoke emotion and nostalgia.

Continue reading
Posted in Feature | Leave a comment

Assembling a 2025 roster for the Nats

Assembling a roster starts with a reality check and that is called the budget. The Washington Nationals have many needs for the offseason, and they have to maximize their opportunities in Dollar/WAR acquisitions. Obviously, Juan Soto‘s +8.1 WAR would be a big plus if the Nationals acquired him — but as we know, Soto will have his choice of suitors. He would almost transform this Nats’ team from 71-wins to 80-wins by himself. The Nationals purged a lot of “addition by subtraction” off of the roster also. Certainly, -4.0 WAR will not be on next year’s roster, and that alone could take this team from 71-wins to 75-wins before any new acquisitions.

Continue reading
Posted in Analysis, Roster | Leave a comment

The Washington Nationals’ Spirited Finale and a Season of Growth

Photo by Andrew Lang for TalkNats

As the curtains fell on the 2024 MLB regular season, the Washington Nationals took the field at Nationals Park with the drive and determination that were characteristic of a team undergoing a profound transformation. Their final game of the 2024 season against the Philadelphia Phillies, despite a 6-3 loss, highlighted both the strides made — and the challenges that remain.

With the Phillies securing a 95-win season, their most impressive record since 2011, we all watched that even a great record in the regular season means little in the postseason as the Phillies were quickly knocked out. Today, it is the offseason for both teams. Baseball can be cruel. Here’s the difference — the Nats were not supposed to make the postseason this year. The Nationals’ journey tells a story of young budding talent and hard-earned experience.

Continue reading
Posted in Feature | Leave a comment

A Hot Dog History: The All-American Bite of Baseball

The hot dog, a culinary staple of American cuisine, has found its perfect partner in the grand spectacle of baseball. The pairing is so iconic that it’s difficult to imagine one without the other. But how did this unlikely duo become so intertwined? Let’s delve into the history of hot dogs at baseball parks.

Continue reading
Posted in Food & Beverages | Leave a comment

The Nats’ Starting Pitcher Conundrum

The Washington Nationals finished 2024 with some surprise reinforcements at Starting Pitcher. Going into 2024, the Nats were reasonably sure MacKenzie Gore, Jake Irvin and Josiah Gray were going to be a part of the rotation going forward. They had veterans Patrick Corbin and Trevor Williams to lean on to share advice to the young core of pitchers but knew they would need to find at least 2 others to fill out a 5-man rotation.

Then one of their young core, Gray, struggled out of the gate and then was placed in the IL due to a flexor strain (a precursor to Tommy John). Looking back, it makes perfect sense he struggled early on if there were structural issues with the arm that later necessitated surgery.

Continue reading
Posted in Analysis, Feature | Leave a comment

2025 Draft Lottery Odds

Another year; another MLB Draft Lottery. Just as we did for the 2023 and 2024 lotteries, a million simulations were run to see the probabilities for all the picks and not just the first pick.

Continue reading
Posted in Analysis, Draft | Leave a comment